Buy the wrong wood shed and the bill arrives twice: once at checkout, and again when a kit you fought for a weekend ends up needing paint, shingles, and trim you did not budget for. These two brands take very different paths to a wood shed. Outdoor Living Today builds premium solid Western Red Cedar in pre-cut panelized walls that arrive ready to stand up, in a tight $3,299 to $9,499 band. Little Cottage Company ships precut, primed LP SmartSide kits across the widest range and most styles of any wood brand we carry, from a $1,479 value barn up to an $11,469 classic. Here is how to pick.
TL;DR: Outdoor Living Today wins on premium real-cedar quality, easier panelized assembly, and curb appeal, with solid Western Red Cedar from $3,299 to $9,499. Little Cottage Company wins on selection: the lowest entry price ($1,479), the most styles, and the widest range ($1,479 to $11,469), including premium tiers that rival OLT, if you do not mind a longer build and buying paint and shingles yourself.
Here is the quick read before the details. Every price below reflects an in-stock model we carry today. Want the full decision framework first? Start with our guide to sizing and buying a shed and come back once you know your size and budget.
| Feature | Outdoor Living Today | Little Cottage Company |
|---|---|---|
| Wood / material | Solid Western Red Cedar | LP SmartSide engineered wood, pre-primed |
| Build type | Pre-cut panelized walls, cladding attached | Precut, labeled DIY kit |
| Styles | Gardener, Sunshed, Space Master, SpaceSaver | Gambrel, gable, colonial, classic lines |
| Price range | $3,299 to $9,499 | $1,479 to $11,469 |
| Customization | Limited; finish color and roof material | High; you supply paint, shingles, trim, layout |
| Assembly | Faster, fewer pieces | Longer, roughly 4 to 8 hours |
No single column wins outright, which is exactly why the right pick depends on what you value most. The sections below break down where each brand earns its price.
Outdoor Living Today builds the shed your neighbors compliment. Every model uses solid Western Red Cedar, with 2x3 wall framing and pre-cut cedar cladding attached to panelized walls, so the pieces arrive ready to bolt together rather than ready to cut. Western red cedar is naturally decay resistant and can be used outdoors without protective coatings, according to Purdue University Extension, which is why an OLT shed looks right the day it goes up and weathers to a soft gray if you leave it unstained.
The trade-off is price, and it is real, though OLT keeps a tighter band than you might expect. The compact SpaceSaver 8x4 double door starts the line at $3,299, while the Gardener 8x8 runs $4,599 with a cedar-shingle roof or $4,199 with galvalume metal. Step up to the Sunshed 8x8 at $5,449, the Sunshed 12x12 at $7,999, or the Space Master 12x16 at $8,399, with the lineup topping out near $9,499. You pay a premium, but you get real cedar, a faster panelized build with less assembly labor, and a finish that needs almost nothing from you. Choose OLT when curb appeal and a 20-plus-year lifespan justify the spend.
Little Cottage Company gives you the most to choose from, full stop. Its sheds ship as precut, labeled, pre-primed kits built from LP SmartSide engineered-wood siding over 2x4 framing, made in the USA with Amish craftsmanship. Treated, durable wood products hold up for decades when properly finished and maintained, as documented by the USDA Forest Products Laboratory, and a primed SmartSide shell is built to take paint and last once you seal it.
What sets LCC apart is reach. It spans the widest price band and the most styles of any wood brand we carry, from value to premium. The value line opens at $1,479 for the Value Gambrel Barn 4’ and $1,569 for the Value Gable, both built for the budget-minded DIYer. From there it climbs through colonial-styled cottages like the Colonial Williamsburg at $2,649, and tops out with the premium Classic Gambrel Large Barn at $4,559 to $11,469, a tier that rivals OLT on price and size. Gambrel, gable, colonial, and classic lines mean there is almost certainly a footprint and roofline to match your yard.
The catch is the finishing work. Kits do not include drip edge, shingles, or paint, so you supply those and the labor, with assembly running roughly 4 to 8 hours. In exchange you get the broadest selection in this matchup and a price for nearly any budget.
Strip away the marketing and three differences drive the choice.
Material and finish. OLT is solid Western Red Cedar that looks finished unstained; Little Cottage is primed LP SmartSide engineered wood that needs your paint and shingles to be weather-tight. One is ready; one is a project. That is the core material distinction: real solid cedar versus a primed wood composite built to be painted.
Price and selection. Little Cottage opens far below OLT, at $1,479 versus $3,299, and stretches well past it at the top, to $11,469, with more styles and footprints along the way. If your budget is tight, your space is odd, or you want a specific roofline, that range matters. Comparing kit brands across this span is worth doing, and our breakdown of EZ-Fit vs Little Cottage Company sheds weighs the other strong engineered-wood option against it.
Effort. OLT panels go up fast with few pieces and less assembly labor; Little Cottage rewards a confident DIYer with a longer, hands-on build.
Match the brand to your top priority and the answer gets simple.
Choose Outdoor Living Today if premium real-cedar quality, easier assembly, and curb appeal matter most. Solid Western Red Cedar, a panelized build with less assembly labor, and a near-finished look out of the box make it the pick for a shed you will see from the patio every day and keep for decades, all in a focused $3,299 to $9,499 band. Browse the cedar lineup in the Outdoor Living Today collection to match a model to your yard.
Choose Little Cottage Company if selection leads. With the lowest entry price in this matchup at $1,479, the most styles across gambrel, gable, colonial, and classic lines, and a range that climbs to $11,469, it covers nearly any budget and yard, including premium tiers that rival OLT, as long as you are comfortable painting, shingling, and spending a weekend on assembly.
It depends on your priority. Outdoor Living Today is better for premium quality, easier assembly, and curb appeal, using solid Western Red Cedar in pre-cut panels that go up fast and need little finishing, in a $3,299 to $9,499 band. Little Cottage Company is better for selection, with primed LP SmartSide kits spanning the widest range of any wood brand we carry, $1,479 to $11,469, across gambrel, gable, colonial, and classic styles, if you do not mind painting and a longer build.
They are a real project but manageable for a confident DIYer. The kits arrive precut, labeled, and pre-primed, and assembly runs roughly 4 to 8 hours depending on size and skill. Plan for two people and remember the kit does not include drip edge, shingles, or paint, so buy those before you start.
Solid Western Red Cedar throughout, with cedar cladding pre-attached to the wall panels and cedar joists in the floor. Cedar is naturally resistant to rot and insects, so OLT sheds can be left unstained to weather gray or sealed to hold their color, with no protective coating strictly required. Cross-shopping cedar brands? Our Outdoor Living Today vs Cedarshed comparison weighs OLT against another premium cedar maker.
Little Cottage Company has the lower entry point, starting at $1,479 for a Value Gambrel Barn 4’ versus $3,299 for OLT’s SpaceSaver 8x4. But LCC is not strictly the cheaper brand: its range climbs to $11,469 for the premium Classic Gambrel Large Barn, well past OLT’s $9,499 ceiling. For a given size, OLT’s solid cedar typically costs more than a comparable LCC engineered-wood kit, in exchange for real cedar and a faster, near-finished build.
{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}
Leave a comment