The Outdoor Plus and Elementi sit at the premium end of the fire pit market, but they pull in opposite stylistic directions. Elementi builds modern, geometric concrete tables at accessible premium prices; The Outdoor Plus builds rustic metal and hammered-copper features with far higher heat output and fire-and-water options. Want clean modern concrete and the best value? Elementi wins. Want maximum heat, metal craftsmanship, or a fire-and-water bowl? The Outdoor Plus takes it. Here is the full comparison across the in-stock Elementi and Outdoor Plus lineups.
TL;DR: Elementi wins on modern design and value, with concrete tables up to 60,000 BTUs from $1,879. The Outdoor Plus wins on heat and metal craftsmanship, with steel and copper pieces reaching 65,000 BTUs in stock and up to 160,000 on custom builds, priced $3,254 to $4,380. Choose Elementi for modern value, The Outdoor Plus for power and metal.
| Aspect | Elementi | The Outdoor Plus | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Design | Modern, geometric concrete | Rustic metal + copper | Preference |
| Heat output | Up to 60,000 BTUs | 65,000 in stock, up to 160,000 custom | The Outdoor Plus |
| Materials | Concrete, GFRC | Powder-coated steel, copper | Tie |
| Specialty | Fire tables | Fire-and-water bowls | The Outdoor Plus |
| Price | $1,879 to $3,899 | $3,254 to $4,380 | Elementi |
This one comes down to taste rather than a clear winner. Elementi commits to a modern, minimalist look: clean lines, geometric shapes, and high-performance concrete in modern and natural finishes. It suits contemporary patios where the fire feature should read as sleek furniture.
The brand leans traditional and rustic, working in hammered copper, antique bronze tones, and powder-coated steel for a warmer, more handcrafted feel. Its pieces look like statement metalwork rather than minimalist tables. If your space is modern, Elementi fits; if it is rustic or transitional, The Outdoor Plus has the character.
The Outdoor Plus takes heat decisively. Its in-stock steel models climb to 65,000 BTUs, as on the Outdoor Plus Round Unity 48-inch, and custom builds climb to a powerful 160,000 BTUs, enough to throw a tall, intense flame across a large yard. Elementi’s hottest tables top out at 60,000 BTUs.
For a standard patio, 45,000 to 60,000 BTUs is plenty, so Elementi is not underpowered. But if you are heating a big, open, or wind-exposed space and want a commanding fire, The Outdoor Plus has output Elementi cannot match. Heat is measured in BTUs, and here the gap is real.
On raw materials it is a tie: Elementi’s reinforced concrete and The Outdoor Plus’s copper and steel are all premium, durable, weather-ready choices. The deciding feature is what one brand offers that the other does not: the fire-and-water bowl. Pieces like the Outdoor Plus Remi Hammered Copper Fire and Water Bowl at $3,432 combine a flame with a water feature for a multisensory centerpiece.
Elementi keeps its focus on concrete tables, with no water-feature line. If you want a fire-and-water statement, only one of these two brands makes one.
Elementi is the clear value leader. Its tables run $1,879 to $3,899, while its rival sits $3,254 to $4,380 in stock and higher on custom work. For durable concrete construction and modern design, Elementi delivers a premium fire feature at a noticeably lower entry point.
That does not make those pieces overpriced. You are paying for hand-worked metal, fire-and-water engineering, and far higher heat ceilings. But for buyers weighing cost against performance, Elementi gives more fire pit per dollar.
Both brands offer made-to-order flexibility, which is why this category lands even. Elementi lets buyers choose the shape, size, surface finish, and color, and its design team works directly with clients on bespoke pieces, including surface etchings and engravings. The result is a concrete table tailored to one specific space.
The Outdoor Plus matches that with extensive made-to-order services, letting customers specify materials, shapes, decorative accents, fuel type, and dimensions. Its metalwork lends itself to custom copper and steel treatments that a stock catalog could never cover. Whichever maker you choose, you can configure the piece around your patio rather than settling for an off-the-shelf unit.
Choose Elementi if you want modern concrete design, the best value, or a sculptural table for a contemporary patio. The Elementi Andes at $2,899 pairs 60,000 BTUs with that modern look.
Choose The Outdoor Plus if you want maximum heat, rustic metal or copper craftsmanship, or a fire-and-water bowl. It is the premium splurge when character and output matter more than price.
It depends on your priorities. Elementi wins on modern design and value, with concrete tables from $1,879. The Outdoor Plus wins on heat (up to 160,000 BTUs on custom builds), metal craftsmanship, and fire-and-water features. Choose Elementi for modern value, The Outdoor Plus for power and rustic character.
The Outdoor Plus, by a wide margin. Its in-stock pits reach 65,000 BTUs and custom models hit 160,000, while Elementi tops out at 60,000. Both heat a normal patio well, but for a large or exposed space that needs a commanding flame, The Outdoor Plus has the output.
It is a single feature that combines a gas flame with a flowing water element, often in hammered copper. The Outdoor Plus specializes in them, pairing the warmth and glow of fire with the sound and movement of water for a multisensory centerpiece. Elementi does not make a fire-and-water line.
Elementi. Its tables start at $1,879 versus The Outdoor Plus’s $3,254-and-up range, so you get durable concrete construction and modern design for less. The Outdoor Plus costs more because you are paying for hand-worked metal, fire-and-water engineering, and higher heat output.
Both brands sit firmly in premium territory, and the choice is about style and priorities. Elementi wins on modern design and value, making it the smart pick for a contemporary patio and the better deal overall. The Outdoor Plus wins on heat, metal and copper craftsmanship, and its signature fire-and-water bowls, making it the splurge when character and raw output lead your list. Decide whether sleek-and-affordable or powerful-and-handcrafted matters more, and the winner is clear.
Andy Wu is the resident backyard products expert and hails from Atlanta, Georgia. His passion for crafting outdoor retreats began in 2003.
As a fellow homeowner, he founded Backyard Oasis to provide top-quality furnishings and equipment, collaborating with leading manufacturers.
His main focus is on sheds and generators!
In his spare time he like to hike the tallest mountains in the world and travel with his family.
{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}
Leave a comment