Skip to content
Buy Now for FAST + FREE Shipping! - ✓ Guaranteed Lowest Prices ✓ Manufacturer Warranties ✓ Exceptional Reviews
Buy Now for FAST + FREE Shipping! - ✓ Guaranteed Lowest Prices ✓ Manufacturer Warranties ✓ Exceptional Reviews
Chiminea vs Fire Pit: Which Backyard Fireplace is Right For You?

Chiminea vs Fire Pit: Which Backyard Fireplace is Right For You?

When choosing an outdoor fireplace, two options rise above the rest - the charismatic chiminea originates from Mexico with its characteristic terracotta construction, while versatile outdoor fire pits take on round, square, and rectangular shapes. Both cast inviting amber hues to set the mood, but have key differences when it comes to portability, structure, heating capability, and more.

This guide provides an in-depth exploration of chimineas versus fire pits, including how to choose between them, usage and care tips, creative customizations, and safety guidance. Let’s stoke our knowledge of chimineas and fire pits to determine the best fit.

Key Takeaways

  • Chimineas have an enclosed chamber, concentrating heat upwards, while fire pits have an open design that radiates heat widely to warm larger areas.

  • Fire pits allow versatile fuel options like wood, gas, or gel cans and make it easy to customize styles for any décor.

  • For safety, allow 5+ feet clearance from structures and flames, prep essentials like a fire extinguisher nearby, and constantly supervise backyard fires.
  • When choosing outdoor fireplaces, factor in portability needs, heating goals, visual appeal, preferred fuels, and maintenance reality before selecting fire pits or chimineas.

A collage of outdoor fireplaces: a rustic chimenea, a flaming fire bowl, a covered fire pit, and a seating area with a chimenea in the background.

Chimineas vs Fire Pits: Key Differences

Chimineas and fire pits share some similarities, but have distinct variances:

Flexibility

Fire pits offer great flexibility for those wanting to move the fire feature around their outdoor space. Their open and often lightweight construction allows easy lifting and transferring to patios, yards, decks, and more. Some fire pits break down into parts for storage or fit inside including carrying cases with handles.

Chimineas traditionally featured clay construction, which made them more cumbersome to move once placed. However, modern metal chimineas provide greater durability and lighter frames. Some include wheeled stands for effortless repositioning. Still, most chimineas work best in a permanent backyard spot to contain mess and prevent cracks.

Structure

The classic fire pit shape leaves the fire open to the environment, allowing heat and light to freely emanate in a 360° radius. Their basin or bowl design gives oxygen to the flames and makes adding/arranging logs easy. Fire pits come in round, square, rectangular, and custom shapes with metallic or stone exteriors.

In contrast, chimineas have a protected chamber surrounding the fire, concentrating heat while emitting flames upward from the safety of its chimney top. This architectural approach helps block wind while funneling smoke vertically. The terracotta clay body insulates well to keep exterior surfaces cool.

Fuel

Fire pits invite versatility in fuel choice - customary options include wood logs, manufactured fire logs, charcoal, or piped-in propane or natural gas. Some fire pits allow gel cans for tabletop ambiance. Multiple fuel choices let owners match burning preferences to the season or occasion.

Chimineas traditionally relied on wood as the sole fuel source to generate flames safely within the enclosure. Logs offer atmospheric crackle and pop for an authentic campfire experience. Now some metal chiminea models integrate gas burner elements at the base for instant, adjustable heat without having to start a wood fire manually.

Heat Output

Big propane fire pits generate far more functional heat over a wide area, making them suitable for multiple people to stay warm as temperatures drop. Strategic fire pit placement allows heat to radiate in a 360° circumference to cover patios and seating areas.

Smaller chimineas emit modest heat levels mainly from the top opening, so they work well for creating “zones” of warmth as opposed to heating full outdoor living spaces. Light jackets may still be required around chimineas in especially cold conditions. Think cozy vs. covering all comfort needs.

Style

Chimineas exude a nostalgic Southwest and Mexican flair with terracotta clay or stucco finishes. Glazed designs feature regional emblems and patterns for an eye-catching focal point. Metal chimineas mimic traditional shapes but vary in finishes from solid neutrals to faux bois wood looks.

Fire pits span a full design spectrum - choose from stone, metal, concrete, and steel models with options from ultra-sleek modern to ruggedly rustic. Mix and match with patio furnishings for a pulled-together look or choose movable units for ultimate flexibility.

The main differences between fire pits and chimineas can be summarized as:

Feature Chiminea Fire Pit
Flexibility Less portable due to weight Highly portable
Structure The enclosed chamber concentrates heat The open design radiates heat
Fuel Traditionally wood; also allows gas Wood, gas, gel, charcoal
Heat Output Lower heat for small spaces High heat for large spaces
Style Southwest themes Range of design options

Now that you've explored the core differences between a chiminea and a fire pit, how do you decide which fire feature fits our lifestyle and goals?

A split image: on the left, a close-up of a fire bowl with burning logs; on the right, a rustic chimenea with flames inside.

How to Choose Between Chimineas and Fire Pits

When weighing your options, be sure to fully evaluate the pros and cons of both fireplace types based on your space, heating needs, preferred functionality, and visual appeal. Reading an in-depth fire pit buyer's guide can help crystallize key considerations before purchasing.

Here are some of the key considerations when weighing chimineas against fire pits:

Flexibility

If you entertain frequently and want to move an outdoor fireplace between a patio, lawn, or garden courtyards, a lightweight fire pit offers maximum mobility. Sturdy handles also allow fire pits to be relocated for yard maintenance.

For a permanent backyard retreat, opt for a chiminea’s stabilizing weight and proportional heat for an intimate experience. Strategically place it to complement outdoor conversation sets or near an Adirondack chair for fireside reading nooks.

Size and Heating Ability

To sufficiently heat larger gathering areas like poolside patios or sprawling decks, open fire pits generate far more ambient warmth to keep guests comfy through the night. Rectangular pits stretch the glow.

Smaller backyard landscapes and seating quarters find an excellent heat and light source in chimineas. Place one near an outdoor sofa or bistro set to create a cozy destination by the fire’s glow.

Visual Elegance

For Southwestern character, an authentic terracotta or clay chiminea ushers tradition with regional symbols and patterns on display. Contemporary metal interpretations allow versatility in finish from matte black to rust looks.

Contemporary, modern, and transitional design schemes effortlessly integrate with fire pits for geometric or organic shapes infused with stone, concrete, porcelain, or steel materials. The design options for fire pits feel endless.

Fuel Type

For classic wood fires reminiscent of camping trips and cabins in the woods, chimineas burn authentic split logs safely within the confines of structured walls and chimney openings. Manufactured logs also work well.

If preferred, convertible propane inserts or rings allow fire pits to burn gas fuel for instant ambiance or switch back to real wood as desired. Some fire pits rely solely on gel cans or propane for tabletop or portable applications where wood proves cumbersome.

Maintenance and Safety

Carefully contained campfires mean chimineas involve less clean-up from stray embers or mess. Windscreens further protect backyard surroundings from heat-related damage. Smaller fires make safety monitoring easy.

Caution comes first with spacious fire pits as open flames have greater access to oxygen, requiring vigilance in keeping fires contained and controlled. Ensure the fire bowl size suits the area while protecting against flying embers by following the fire pit safety rules.

A fire pit with a burning log, a table with wine glasses and a bottle, and a chimenea in the background.

Chiminea vs Fire Pit - Which is Better Overall?

Ultimately, fire pits are a superior choice for any backyard fireplace. Chimineas simply can't compete with the expansive size, shape, material, and heating power possibilities of fire pits. Fire pits invite creativity in design to become true backyard centerpieces. Their versatility also ensures comfort and enjoyment for any gathering, big or small. For flexibility and function, fire pits are a clear choice.

FAQs

What are fire pits made of?

Fire pits are often made of durable materials such as steel or cast iron, but they can also be made of cast aluminum, copper, or even concrete. The choice of material impacts the fire pit's appearance, longevity, and price. Steel fire pits and cast iron fire pits are popular for their durability and rustic appeal.

What are the types of fire each of these outdoor heating options is better suited for?

Fire pits are best suited for larger, open fires. This is because a fire pit is an open design, allowing for both more fuel and oxygen, which are necessary for bigger fires. Chimineas, however, are better for small fires. Their enclosed design channels smoke up and away, making it more comfortable for people to sit around, but it also limits the amount of oxygen, thus controlling the size of the fire.

How do the heat distribution and capacity compare between a chiminea and a fire pit?

Fire pits generally have a greater heat capacity than chimineas because they can accommodate larger fires. The heat from a fire pit radiates in all directions, making it a good choice if you want to provide warmth for a larger group. A chiminea, by contrast, is specifically designed to channel heat out through its opening, making it more effective for heating a smaller, specific area.

Is it easy to move the chiminea or fire pit?

The ease of moving either a chiminea or a fire pit largely depends on the size and material. Cast iron chimineas and steel fire pits, for example, can be quite heavy and therefore more difficult to move. Conversely, smaller models, particularly those made from materials like cast aluminum, are more portable. Always ensure the fire is completely out and the unit has cooled before attempting to move it.

Can I cook using a chiminea or a fire pit?

Yes, you can cook using both a chiminea and a fire pit. For fire pits, you can easily grill food items by setting a grill gate on top, whereas a chiminea can also accommodate a grill or can just be used to roast marshmallows or warm up food in foil. However, do keep in mind that whatever you use to cook will get very hot, so use proper cooking gloves and utensils to prevent burns.

Previous article Duraflame vs Solo Stove Fire Pits: Which Smokeless Fire Pit is Better?
Next article Wood Fire Pits vs Gas Fire Pits: Choose the Right Fire Pit

Leave a comment

Comments must be approved before appearing

* Required fields

About The Author

Andy Wu - Resident Expert

Andy Wu - Resident Expert

Andy Wu is the resident backyard products expert and hails from Atlanta, Georgia. His passion for crafting outdoor retreats began in 2003.

As a fellow homeowner, he founded Backyard Oasis to provide top-quality furnishings and equipment, collaborating with leading manufacturers.

His main focus is on sheds and generators!

In his spare time he like to hike the tallest mountains in the world and travel with his family.

Compare products

{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}

Select first item to compare

Select second item to compare

Select third item to compare

Compare